Jump to content

Worst SWFC Player of the past 10 years (Owlstalk Ratings)


Recommended Posts

13 hours ago, areNOTwhatTHEYseem said:

 

I think it's safe to say that none of the above are going to feature in this list.

 

:duntmatter:

 

13 hours ago, SwellOwl said:


You may want to read the thread again..

 

11 hours ago, OneManBand said:

Shoulda gone to specsavers.


FFS 😂 

 

Yeah I replied to the wrong thread.

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Bakewell Owl said:

George Boyd, just here for a last pay packet.

Jacob Butterfield, not interested

Jeremy Helan, not committed to football

Kachunga PHHHFF

Mc Geady orrible

Van Aken, what was the point?

Jaden Brown

Izzy Brown

couldn't make a good Brown with bits of both of them

Pelupessey, last name on the team sheet for me.

and finally Butterfield again, just because I can

 

 

Fu*k me, we've had some right wasters to put up with!

 

Purely & simply, unashamed soccer mercenaries, stealing a living from our club......😡🤬

 

What really hurts, is that not one of them will actually give a sh*t!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Bakewell Owl said:

George Boyd, just here for a last pay packet.

Jacob Butterfield, not interested

Jeremy Helan, not committed to football

Kachunga PHHHFF

Mc Geady orrible

Van Aken, what was the point?

Jaden Brown

Izzy Brown

couldn't make a good Brown with bits of both of them

Pelupessey, last name on the team sheet for me.

and finally Butterfield again, just because I can

 

 

Izzy Brown..is that a question 🤔 

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Bakewell Owl said:

George Boyd, just here for a last pay packet.

Jacob Butterfield, not interested

Jeremy Helan, not committed to football

Kachunga PHHHFF

Mc Geady orrible

Van Aken, what was the point?

Jaden Brown

Izzy Brown

couldn't make a good Brown with bits of both of them

Pelupessey, last name on the team sheet for me.

and finally Butterfield again, just because I can

 

 

Butterfield, think we ruined him..never gave him a chance. Rest of them yes absolute waste

 

 

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 minutes ago, Luke said:

Who cares

A minimum requirement for a player is 100% commitment 

Adam Reach couldn't even do that 

 

The 209 appearances and 5 different managers say different 

  • Like 4
  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, A47Owl said:

Absolute no brainer. No competition. End of thread. Useless individual. 

 

I haven't got round to counting up the 2012-13 season, so for now, Jay Bothroyd is ineligible for this award. Gives the rest of the field a chance.

  • Love 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stephen McPhail was a huge disappointment for me. Remember watching a game away at Derby when he and Seyi Olofinjana were in CM and swear they never got within 5 yards of their opposite numbers. Never have I seen a slower footballer than McPhail and he didn’t look fit when playing for us but started most of the games he was there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

44 minutes ago, Dylan93 said:

Pelupessy is enough for me. Worse player I’ve seen, by a country mile.  Had the likes of Hooper, Fletcher, Wallace, Lee, Bazza and FF all around him and still played like a donkey.

Have you not kind of negated your own point there though?

 

You've listed him alongside players that he isn't at the level of, he's going to look out of place then isn't he?

 

It's like taking a good Championship player and putting him in City's team, he'll look poor in comparison won't he?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 hours ago, Emerson Thome said:

As there was some speculation about the worst players on the other thread, I've decided to do an alternate countdown for the worst 10 players as well. While the best player has to have played at least 25 games, I've decided to open this category up to players with at least 10 starts, to let a few more wildcards enter the field. This will be hotly contested. The full list of players to choose from are:

 

10 SWFC appearances or more, 2013/14-2021/22 seasons (alphabetical order):

ABDI, Almen (Yes, really)

ADENIRAN, Dennis

ANTONIO, Michail

BAKER, Ash

BANNAN, Barry

BERAHINO, Saido

BEST, Leon

BORNER, Julian

BOYD, George

BRENNAN, Ciaran

BROWN, Jaden

BUTTERFIELD, Jacob

BUXTON, Lewis

BYERS, George

COKE, Giles

DAWSON, Cameron

DELE-BASHIRU, Fisayo

DIELNA, Claude

DUNKLEY, Chey

FLETCHER, Steven

FORESTIERI, Fernando

FOX, Morgan

GREGORY, Lee

HARRIS, Kadeem

HECTOR, Michael

HELAN, Jeremy

HOOPER, Gary

HUNT, Jack

HUTCHINSON, Sam

IORFA, Dominic

JOAO, Lucas

JOHNSON, Marvin

JOHNSON, Reda

JOHNSON, Roger

JONES, David

KACHUNGA, Elias

KAMBERI, Florian

KEANE, Will

KIRKLAND, Chris

LAVERY, Caolan

LEE, Kieran

LEES, Tom

LLERA, Miguel

LOOVENS, Glenn

LOPEZ, Alex

LUONGO, Massimo

MAGHOMA, Jacques

MAGUIRE, Chris

MARTINEZ, Emiliano ('Damian')

MATIAS, Marco

MATTOCK, Joe

MAY, Stevie

McGEADY, Aiden

McGUGAN, Lewis

McPHAIL, Stephen

MENDEZ-LAING, Nathaniel

MURPHY, Jacob

NUHIU, Adthe

ODUBAJO, Moses

ONOMAH, Josh

ONYEWU, Oguchi

PALMER, Liam

PATERSON, Callum

PEACOCK-FARRELL, Bailey

PELUPESSY, Joey

PENNEY, Matt

PUDIL, Daniel

REACH, Adam

RHODES, Jordan

SASSO, Vincent

SEMEDO, Jose

SHAW, Liam

SHODIPO, Mide

SOUGOU, Modou

STOREY, Jordan

THORNILEY, Jordan

TURNER, Michael

URHOGHIDE, Osaze

VAN AKEN, Joost

VENANCIO, Frederico

WALLACE, Ross

WESTWOOD, Keiren

WICKHAM, Connor

WILDSMITH, Joe

WINDASS, Josh

WINNALL, Sam

ZAYATTE, Kamil

 

Jadon brown 

Ash Baker 

Pelupessy

May

Mattock

Butterfield

 

All just simply out of their depth 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Bakewell Owl said:

George Boyd, just here for a last pay packet.

Jacob Butterfield, not interested

Jeremy Helan, not committed to football

Kachunga PHHHFF

Mc Geady orrible

Van Aken, what was the point?

Jaden Brown

Izzy Brown

couldn't make a good Brown with bits of both of them

Pelupessey, last name on the team sheet for me.

and finally Butterfield again, just because I can

 

 

I’ll defend a couple of these but broadly I agree agree. I thought Boyd always put in the effort. Helan played ok when he had Reda behind him, they made a decent left side pairing. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Abdi 

Jaden Brown 

Butterfield 

David Jones

Kachunga

Stevie May

McPhail

Shopido

 

I almost wanna put Kadeem Harris in there for just how poor he was in our relegation season, but he played a lot of games for us and always put in a shift I suppose

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Fibonacci91 said:

Abdi 

Jaden Brown 

Butterfield 

David Jones

Kachunga

Stevie May

McPhail

Shopido

 

I almost wanna put Kadeem Harris in there for just how poor he was in our relegation season, but he played a lot of games for us and always put in a shift I suppose

Oh ye...Moses was a shocker

 

 

 

Harsh on those putting Pelupessy in there, he was limited but tried and played a lot of football for us. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

In terms of actual footballing ability. Jeremy Helan will take some beating,  somebody clearly saw him running, offered him a contract and assumed they could teach him the football part later.  

Edited by Lee A
  • Like 3
  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...