Jump to content

Karen Carney vs Leeds United


Recommended Posts

She has really p**see them off! 
 

I kind of get what she is saying - the covid break helped the squad recover. Which is a massive boost to them with the style of play they employ and the way they faded the season before.

 

They call out all pundits, clubs and managers who make negative comments (bit tinpot) so I think the sexist calls are wide of the mark.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think she was talking utter nonsense tbh.

 

Leeds pre-lockdown won 5 on the bounce without conceding a single goal.

 

Their record in the first 5 games back was 3 wins, a draw and, a loss.  The loss came against Cardiff and, they drew with Luton (coincidently within their first 3 games back). Hardly an improvement is it?

Considering there were only 9 games left in the season when it restarted, they’d done the donkey work. Her comments were off the mark and, she’s rightly been criticised for it. 
 

Pundits shouldn’t be exempt from criticism, they shouldn’t however have to face any form of abuse. The tweet Leeds made didn’t incite abuse IMO and, they have nothing to apologise for.

 

  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, 0wl18 said:

Pundits shouldn’t be exempt from criticism, they shouldn’t however have to face any form of abuse. The tweet Leeds made didn’t incite abuse IMO and, they have nothing to apologise for.

 

 

 

Agree, she was off the mark and didn't need to bring it up and when she did it sounded like she has something against Leeds (maybe she does but that doesn't need to be put in full view to everyone)

 

But the bit I've highlighted - pundits these days are awful for the most part and if we started criticise we'd blow up the internet!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If she’d have said that, the style of play Leeds have, coupled with the ridiculously congested fixture list we’ve got this season, would potentially result in Leeds burning out, she’d be spot on. 
 

Its the correlation she tried to make between the break last year and, Leeds winning promotion.

 

A team who have won 5 on the bounce without conceding a single goal, do not want the season to end. They’d have romped home. The lockdown didn’t affect that. They were the best team in the league before COVID, they ended the season as the best in the league with COVID. 
 

She probably just got her words mixed up and, didn’t make the point she meant to. Unfortunately when you’re a paid ‘expert’ you’re not going to get away with it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, 0wl18 said:

I think she was talking utter nonsense tbh.

 

Leeds pre-lockdown won 5 on the bounce without conceding a single goal.

 

Their record in the first 5 games back was 3 wins, a draw and, a loss.  The loss came against Cardiff and, they drew with Luton (coincidently within their first 3 games back). Hardly an improvement is it?

Considering there were only 9 games left in the season when it restarted, they’d done the donkey work. Her comments were off the mark and, she’s rightly been criticised for it. 
 

Pundits shouldn’t be exempt from criticism, they shouldn’t however have to face any form of abuse. The tweet Leeds made didn’t incite abuse IMO and, they have nothing to apologise for.

 

 

You make good points. Pundits sometimes have to rely on being outspoken or controversial, which for a woman in a predominately male environment is a dangerous thing to do. However, I think most fans would respect well inform opinion from anyone, but as you say she was clearly wrong in this regards.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Animis said:

 

You make good points. Pundits sometimes have to rely on being outspoken or controversial, which for a woman in a predominately male environment is a dangerous thing to do. However, I think most fans would respect well inform opinion from anyone, but as you say she was clearly wrong in this regards.


Chris Sutton is a prime example of this. At this stage he is almost a parody of himself always trying to get someone riled up.

 

Failed manager trying to hound others out of the job. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, 0wl18 said:

I think she was talking utter nonsense tbh.

 

Leeds pre-lockdown won 5 on the bounce without conceding a single goal.

 

Their record in the first 5 games back was 3 wins, a draw and, a loss.  The loss came against Cardiff and, they drew with Luton (coincidently within their first 3 games back). Hardly an improvement is it?

Considering there were only 9 games left in the season when it restarted, they’d done the donkey work. Her comments were off the mark and, she’s rightly been criticised for it. 
 

Pundits shouldn’t be exempt from criticism, they shouldn’t however have to face any form of abuse. The tweet Leeds made didn’t incite abuse IMO and, they have nothing to apologise for.

 

It might not have directly incited abuse but if you’ve spent any time of twitter you’ll know what an utter cesspit it is. Zero doubt that tweet from Leeds will have led to Karen being inundated with vile comments. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, HighworthOwl said:


Chris Sutton is a prime example of this. At this stage he is almost a parody of himself always trying to get someone riled up.

 

Failed manager trying to hound others out of the job. 

Sutton is a total joke. Controversial for the sake of it. Takes some doing to make Robbie Savage look rational. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, owls maniac said:

It might not have directly incited abuse but if you’ve spent any time of twitter you’ll know what an utter cesspit it is. Zero doubt that tweet from Leeds will have led to Karen being inundated with vile comments. 

That’s down to the individuals sending the vile abuse.

 

Should Amazon pull all highlights so idiots don’t send file abuse to anyone with a differing opinion to them?

 

It’s down to Social Media to stamp it out. The vile individuals will always exist. Remove the anonymity Twitter and, other platforms can provide, make users provide So form of ID check. Let’s see how much abuse gets handed out when there’s accountability.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...