Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
WayneTheOwl

Squad Value - Your Estimate?

Recommended Posts

I know this is all fantasy value based but put yourself in the place of MM.

 

A football club losing 5-6m a year, currently positioned nicely in the league where we don't probably have to worry about relegation that much (not with Blackpool/Rotherham/Millwall and Leeds all down there anyhow) (how nice does that sound), 2 home games to come (then Reading away which recently we always seem to beat the,) which are both winnable putting us onto 43 points. Relegation no chance as we would only need say 12 points from 19 games (even we couldn't blow that). Realistically play offs is in reach but which comes first, balance the books or finance a few more signings? Stick or Twist? If he sticks then why not sell 10m worth of talent (Lees, Westwood, Dielna/Nuhiu/Helan) which covers the debt for this and most of next season.

 

Basically the next 2-3 games could well play MM's hand in accepting any offers for players who's arses are being sniffed by the Premier League clubs.

 

I just hope that if there is a Thai takeover then they have specified we do not sell our most valuable assets!

 

Just thought I would chuck this one in, I am off to steer us lot to the Premier League on Fifa 15 now!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Evening all. Just starting to come down from the dizzy heights after being knocked down to 9th position and am a little bored so just thought what fellow Owls thought of the current squad transfer value per player. Not doing every player but mine are below:

 

Westwood - 4M

Kirkland - 500K

Buxton - 100K

Palmer - 1.5M

Loovens - 250K

Lees - 3.5M

Zayatte - 100K

Dielna - 600K

Mattock - 400K

Helan - 1.75M

Semedo - 300K

Lee - 800K

Hutchinson - 200K (only based on injuries)

Maghoma - 500K

Maguire - 1M

May - 750K

Nuhiu - 750K

Lavery - 300K

Coke - 0K

Madine - 100K

 

Comes to a total of around 17 million in value.

 

Have a go for fun lads see what your estimates are.

The value of anything is only what somebody is prepared to pay for it. We can't know what others would be prepared to pay for our players.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The value of anything is only what somebody is prepared to pay for it. We can't know what others would be prepared to pay for our players.

Think it's more of a 'if a team bid for a player...what minimum fee would we be looking for'

For example, if someone bid 100k for Palmer we wouldn't accept it. 

  • Agree 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

Westwood -                                   3M

Kirkland -                                                200K

Buxton -                                                 100K

Palmer -                                      1.5M

Loovens -                                              400K

Lees -                                          4.M

Zayatte -                                               300K

Dielna -                                        1M

Mattock -                                             500K

Helan -                                     2.5M

Semedo -                                            400K

Lee - 800K

Hutchinson -                                     -

Maghoma -                                         700K

Maguire -                                   1M

May -                                         1M

Nuhiu -                                               750K

Lavery -                                             500K

Coke -                                                200K

Madine -                                             100K

 

 

I got it at just over 18M 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

To me Lees value to us goes up about 500k per clean sheet I have him at about 10m so far

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Think it's more of a 'if a team bid for a player...what minimum fee would we be looking for'

For example, if someone bid 100k for Palmer we wouldn't accept it. 

 

I don't think he'll get it even with that simple and reasonable definition. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Evening all. Just starting to come down from the dizzy heights after being knocked down to 9th position and am a little bored so just thought what fellow Owls thought of the current squad transfer value per player. Not doing every player but mine are below:

Westwood - 4M

Kirkland - 500K

Buxton - 100K

Palmer - 1.5M

Loovens - 250K

Lees - 3.5M

Zayatte - 100K

Dielna - 600K

Mattock - 400K

Helan - 1.75M

Semedo - 300K

Lee - 800K

Hutchinson - 200K (only based on injuries)

Maghoma - 500K

Maguire - 1M

May - 750K

Nuhiu - 750K

Lavery - 300K

Coke - 0K

Madine - 100K

Comes to a total of around 17 million in value.

Have a go for fun lads see what your estimates are.

Palmer 1.5 million??? What you been smoking

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Evening all. Just starting to come down from the dizzy heights after being knocked down to 9th position and am a little bored so just thought what fellow Owls thought of the current squad transfer value per player. Not doing every player but mine are below:

Westwood - 4M

Kirkland - 500K

Buxton - 100K

Palmer - 1.5M

Loovens - 250K

Lees - 3.5M

Zayatte - 100K

Dielna - 600K

Mattock - 400K

Helan - 1.75M

Semedo - 300K

Lee - 800K

Hutchinson - 200K (only based on injuries)

Maghoma - 500K

Maguire - 1M

May - 750K

Nuhiu - 750K

Lavery - 300K

Coke - 0K

Madine - 100K

Comes to a total of around 17 million in value.

Have a go for fun lads see what your estimates are.

Way off mate. £17m? We're on about selling club for £30m.

Only players worth decent money are Westwood - £3m, Lees - £2.5m, Palmer £1m. Rest of our best would be in 000's

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Palmer 1.5 million??? What you been smoking

Young, British, can play a number of positions capably, came through our academy, current player of the season & a constant part of the 2nd best defence in the league.

 

It's a fair valuation. 

  • Agree 1
  • Disagree 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Westwood - £3M

Kirkland - £100K

Buxton - £100K

Palmer - £600K

Loovens - £200K

Lees - £2.5M

Zayatte - £200K

Dielna - £700K

Mattock - £400K

Helan - £800K

Semedo - £100K

Lee - £800K

Hutchinson - £300K

Maghoma - £500K

Maguire - £800K

May - £1.5M

Nuhiu - £1M

Lavery - £300K

Coke - £100K

Madine - £100K

Just over £14 million for me. Most saleable asset is Westwood, closely followed by Lees.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's amazing isn't it really becoz I don't think he's been great this year, but the defence as a whole have good stats so we can't moan too much be he's dissapointed me

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Difference from the original post:

Kirkland 150k

Palmer 200k

Dielna 1m

Mattock 750k

Helan 750k

Maghoma 50k

May 600k

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't think he'll get it even with that simple and reasonable definition. 

 

There are 2 ways of looking at valuation - of pretty much everything

 

How much is the player/commodity worth to the owner? - ie what is the minimum amount below which the owner will not sell

 

And how much is somebody else prepared to pay?

 

If we need to sell a player and he will be going regardless then the "value" is dictated by the buying club - ie what they will pay for him

 

If a club really want one of our players and aggressively pursue them (but we don't need/want to sell) - then in that case the valuation is set by how much money we require before parting with the player

 

In both regards valuation is an abstract concept

  • Agree 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Westwood - 5M

Kirkland - 300K

Buxton - 500K

Palmer - 2M

Loovens - 200k

Lees - 4M

Zayatte - 100K

Dielna - 2M (Once we've seen more of him consistently)

Mattock - 400K

Helan - 1.5M

Semedo - 600K

Lee - 1.3M

Hutchinson - 1.5M (Fully fit)

Maghoma - 500K

Maguire - 1M

May - 1M

Nuhiu - 750K

Lavery - 800K

Coke - 100K

Madine - 100K

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Westwood - 6M

Kirkland - 850K

Buxton - 150K

Palmer - 1.5M

Loovens - 350K

Lees - 3.5M

Zayatte - 300K

Dielna - 500K

Mattock - 300K

Helan - 1M

Semedo - 100K

Lee - 600K

Hutchinson - 400K

Maghoma - 400K

Maguire - 500k

May - 1.5m

Nuhiu - 450K

Lavery - 500K

Coke - 50K

Madine - 50K

£18.95M

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Palmer is an easy 1.5M as mentioned above by FlyingOwl!

 

Yet some put coke at 500K (no offence Nev!).

 

Very interesting how much variation there is. The people want think most of the players are worth nowt are a little silly. Once a team is performing well and in the top 10 of the league, the players valuations automatically increase as does the scouting on these players as we are finding out for the first time in 15 years!

  • Disagree 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...