Jump to content

George Whitebread

  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by George Whitebread

  1. Very similar... but at a higher level. He was the best player in the Championship in an awful team. Would've improved any other side and some in the top flight. Bannan is one of the best in League One in a yet-to-find-its-feet team, and would improve every other side plus some in the Championship.
  2. Sibon was the best player at the club by an absolute mile for the entire duration of his time at the club. Aside fro Di Canio, the best we've seen at Hillsborough since the heady days of Hirst, Waddle, Sheridan, Walker, Nilsson...etc.
  3. Despite the p!55 taking, you're not alone. Both sides' shirts that were predominantly white from the back (90%ish Wednesday, 67%ish Sunderland), and both wore black shorts. And, yes, the electronic ad boards are flippin' 'orrible.
  4. All fit & no suspensions.... --------------- Westwood -------------- Iorfa ----- Lees -- Hutch - Borner ----------- Lee ------ Bannon ---------- Reach ----- Forestieri ------ Harris ----------------- Fletcher -----------------
  5. Would Palmer have been the preferred left back in any of the promoted sides last season? Or any of the five play-off sides that failed to gain promotion? Or any of the three that came down? Or any sides that weren't relegated from the Championship? He's "good enough" to stand in for a proper left back for a game or maybe even a few. He's not a promotion winning campaign-long left back. If Fox is capable of delivering superb crosses (note, plural!), he actively chooses not to, which is arguably even worse!
  6. Come on, less of the negativity. We'll not lose by that much!
  7. He's not a scapegoat. He's not being blamed for anything. He's just not very good. If we can get away with your 3-3-2-3 formation, I think we're golden. Most refs will spot it though.
  8. I didn't think it was an unreasonable request, assuming we are actually looking to push for one of those top six places, that is.
  9. Just to be clear, I'm NOT criticising Palmer's performance against Reading because (a) this thread is about the whole season, not one game, and (b) I didn't go, so can only go by highlights which don't show enough. (From the video, perhaps he should've done better in terms of preventing their best chance @ 1.20, probably should've stuck with Meite for their goal rather than drifting into no man's land just before the cross, and did well to cut across and get a shot away in he second half. And, it's a bit of a stretch to claim that he suddenly offers an attacking threat because he has an "assist" under his belt after a hopeful chip from inside his own half - that goal was all about Harris!) I'm also NOT saying that he's incapable of doing a job as a placeholder. He's an OK fair-to-middling Championship squad player. But there's no way on God's green earth that he's a permanent solution at left back for a club with ambitions of anything beyond treading water. So, what I'm getting at is that if we don't bring a proper left back in, that probably tells us everything we need to know about the season ahead - especially after selling Joao. I understand that some want to leap to his defence (despite him not really being attacked!), but the desire to stand by your own shouldn't prevent you from applying some objectivity. It's not disloyal to recognise that he's not even a left-back! Yes, his positional sense is generally there or thereabouts (odd mistake can be forgiven) and he gets a foot in. So, he's not awful defensively (at right back) by any means. But he's not a footballer (in the total football sense, that is). His first touch, passing, crossing, speed of thought, and general ball skills are just not what is needed at the top end of the Championship. If we were starting the season with him at right back, having signed a good left back, I'd still be disappointed with the lack of ambition, but significantly less worried. If anything, perhaps it would be better to have Palmer in his preferred position and Odebajo at left back, for now. Either way, we need a proper left back. Another season of making do will consign us to a mid-table, at best, finish.
  10. There're nothing tired old or even Owlstalk related about it. My view on Palmer's inability to play at a level required for a side looking to push for promotion is based on watching him play. He might be OK as a squad player if we end up with a string of injuries mid-season, but he can't be our first choice left-back for the season, surely?!
  11. How can we still be waiting for what should've been priority #1 to be solved? Liam Palmer obviously isn't good enough at right-back, let alone on the wrong side, trying to use his standing foot! But even playing out of position he's better than Fox. Thorniley offers cover off the bench if there's an injury and we need to see a game out. But he's not mobile enough to be a starting LB and his crossing is only just better than Fox/Palmer's. When is Penney back? He's probably too light-weight defensively, really. But he showed signs of being able to cross a ball. So, could he do a job there against weaker opposition? (I see him more as back up for Harris if we revert to a 4-4-2 though really) Is Odubajo going to make the switch once Iorfa's back? He's better than Palmer, but can another right-back really be a permanent solution? Surely, we're going to sign an actual left back? Surely?! If not, this is always going to be the ch_ ink in our armour and every opposition manager knows there's at least a goal or two available for them if they keep targeting that side.
  12. I think his problem can be summed up as follows... Joao is better than Winnall. Nuhiu is better than Winnall. Forestieri is better than Winnall. Fletcher is better than Winnall. Hooper is better than Winnall. Shame for the lad. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
  13. It'd be great to finish in the top 10. Something to build on for next season.
  14. It's more likely that we'll finish in the bottom half than the top half? BS!
  15. If we beat Derby, talk of playoff potential will inevitably follow. I was starting to let myself get carried away with it, so decided to look in a bit more detail... The chasing pack and their projected points, if they carry on at their current rate, are... Brizzle - 73 Derby - 71 Brum - 66 Forest - 66 Hull - 66 Villa - 63 Preston - 63 Wednesday - 63 Our current form is obviously stronger than looking at the season as a whole would suggest. But even if we beat Derby and assume we'll also beat Brizzle later (so the gap between us and them is closed to 3 points - currently 6), it's still a massive ask. It basically means we'll need to win 8 & draw 1 (so we can only lose 2) or win 7 and & draw 4 (so no margin for error). We still have Norwich, Leeds, Forest, Villa & Preston to play. So, even if we beat everyone that is currently below us, we still need 3 wins and 2 draws from teams above us. Who knows. It might happen. But it doesn't look likely, unfortunately. Here's the most positive forecast that I can muster (without being silly)...
  16. I've said it before and I'll say it again... Pelupessi would be our best option at right back right now. If we could get Penny in at left back too. We'd be OK. Even better if Hutchinson could replace Lees alongside Hector. A full back line that can both defend and play football. I might as well finish my team (when all fit) while I'm here... Bannan & Lee in CM Reach & Forestieri on the wings Hooper & Fletcher up top We'd win every game however many we want, nil.
  17. I always enjoyed being pulled off at halftime, to be fair.
  18. I know what you're saying. I used to go home and away, rain or shine, regardless of whether we were losing every week or winning. But I'm at a time in my life where I can't justify taking every other Saturday and the occasional weeknight away from my wife n kids, or spending money that we could spend on other things, if it's not going to be at least half entertaining. The Derby game was good. He almost got the team right for a change (barring Fox, obviously, and playing Forrestieri and Reach the wrong way around). If tonight is similar, I might start to chnge my tune. But if he persists with playing ultra-negative boring crap, I've got better things to do with my time and money.
  19. No chance of me renewing with Luhukay still at the club. None.
  20. Duffy wasn't just "looking for" the contact. He made the contact.
  21. Fair enough. I didn't think he was supposed to be out for long when he picked up a knock. Then with us having a string of top table opposition, it seemed as though Jos was being ultra-defensive, as seems to be his default setting. It doesn't help that he's only started 3 games at Hillsborough and he was taken off despite playing well on about 70 mins on all three occasions.
  • Create New...