Jump to content

Player ratings


Ronio

Recommended Posts

Westwood  9 - Immense today, kept us in the game. Fantastic save from the pen and another clean sheet. MoM for me.

 

Palmer     6  -  Not his best game today.  

Loovens   7  -  Solid as usual and gives us that experience at the back.

Lees         9  -  Rock solid today, put in a series of quality tackles and headers from the back.  

Mattock    7  -  Reliable at the back, unlucky not to score second half

 

Maguire    6  - Hasn't looked his usual self.  

Semedo    8 -  Another great performances from Semedo.  Great run down the left to set up Hope.

Coke         6 -  Didn't have the greatest impact today.

Maghoma 7 -  Started pretty lively, did a decent job when moved to the centre.

 

Nuhiu        7 - Worked his socks off as usual. Unlucky to not get a pen having been dragged down in the box.

May           8 - Worked the channels well, did well to get the ball in back of net.

 

 

Hope         7 - Looked very lively, and unlucky not to score today.

Helan         7  - Did what was needed when coming on.  

Dielna        6  - Wasn't on the pitch long enough to have an impact.  Helped keep it tight at the back in the end.

 

 

Referee      0  absolutely shocking refereeing today.  Worst i've seen in a while.

 

Gray          10  Got the lineup and subs absolutely spot on today.

 

Fantastic win today and we are sat nicely in 6th place.

 

Thoughts?

Edited by Ronio
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting ratings. Who were the players who were consistently beaten in the air from corners, it seemed like we had a real problem with their set plays

Are you ever happy?

Reading look a strong side from set pieces, I think they'll trouble a number of sides from them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Westwood - 10

Palmer - 6

Loovens - 6

Lees - 8

Mattock - 7

Maguire - 6

Coke - 5

Semedo - 8

Maghoma - 6

May - 7

Nuhiu - 6

No real stand out performers. But as a team we were brilliant. So tight and hard to beat. Never look like conceding. Need more threatening attacks though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest JonTheOwl66

Westwood - 10

Palmer - 6

Loovens - 6

Lees - 8

Mattock - 7

Maguire - 6

Coke - 5

Semedo - 8

Maghoma - 6

May - 7

Nuhiu - 6

No real stand out performers. But as a team we were brilliant. So tight and hard to beat. Never look like conceding. Need more threatening attacks though.

 

No outstanding performers but Westwood is a 10?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Westwood - 10

Palmer - 6

Loovens - 6

Lees - 8

Mattock - 7

Maguire - 6

Coke - 5

Semedo - 8

Maghoma - 6

May - 7

Nuhiu - 6

No real stand out performers. But as a team we were brilliant. So tight and hard to beat. Never look like conceding. Need more threatening attacks though.

This is key, it's not always easy to achieve that balance We've got something good going on here, so we don't want to weaken the unit

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Westwood - 9.5   Exceptional when called into action

Palmer - 6  Marginally off his best today
Loovens - 6 Knocked off a point for that rick in the second half that nearly cost us
Lees - 8  - Immense
Mattock - 7  Sound

Maguire - 6  -  Not been the same player so far this season
Coke - 6  Did OK. PLayed quite deep
Semedo - 8 OK for 60 minutes and a giant for the last 20
Maghoma - 7 Started really well but faded a bit

May - 7  Worked hard against some pretty agricultural defending
Nuhiu 7  As for May

 

Helan  -  7 Cameo but highish mark because he made a positive difference

Hope - 6.5 Quite lively

 

Dielna - Came on too late to judge

 

Referee -  as bad as I've seen

 

Assistant refs - Played their parts in helping the ref have a shocker

Edited by Dagmeister
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Westwood  9 - Immense today, kept us in the game. Fantastic save from the pen and another clean sheet. MoM for me.

 

Palmer     6  -  Not his best game today.  

Loovens   7  -  Solid as usual and gives us that experience at the back.

Lees         9  -  Rock solid today, put in a series of quality tackles and headers from the back.  

Mattock    7  -  Reliable at the back, unlucky not to score second half

 

Maguire    6  - Hasn't looked his usual self.  

Semedo    8 -  Another great performances from Semedo.  Great run down the left to set up Hope.

Coke         6 -  Didn't have the greatest impact today.

Maghoma 7 -  Started pretty lively, did a decent job when moved to the centre.

 

Nuhiu        7 - Worked his socks off as usual. Unlucky to not get a pen having been dragged down in the box.

May           8 - Worked the channels well, did well to get the ball in back of net.

 

 

Hope         7 - Looked very lively, and unlucky not to score today.

Helan         7  - Did what was needed when coming on.  

Dielna        6  - Wasn't on the pitch long enough to have an impact.  Helped keep it tight at the back in the end.

 

 

Referee      0  absolutely shocking refereeing today.  Worst i've seen in a while.

 

Gray          10  Got the lineup and subs absolutely spot on today.

 

Fantastic win today and we are sat nicely in 6th place.

 

Thoughts?

Pretty much spot on, though id say Maguire was decent at times so a 7.

 

May a real handful today and Lees and Westwood BRILLIANT.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting ratings. Who were the players who were consistently beaten in the air from corners, it seemed like we had a real problem with their set plays

 

Reading have obviously worked on their corners. They were especially dangerous in the second half; knocked beyond the far post where one of their big men kept finding space from quite deep.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Westwood - 8 Saved a penalty a couple of other really good saves.

Mattock - 7 solid enough, some good attacking play.

Loovens - 7 Good pperformance.didn't win everything though.

Lees - 7 See Loovens.

Palmer - 6 Thought he was a bit poor today. Looks happier going forward.

Maghoma - 7 Carried a threat going forward but sometimes makes the wrong decision.

Semedo -8 Excellent at breaking up play. Even got into the box today!

Coke -7 Solid enough without setting the world on fire.

Macguire -5 Simple passes went astray, shooting poor. Be lucky to reyain his place on recent performances.

May -8 Never stopped running, scored and looked more threatening than he has before.

Nuhiu -7 Not his best match. Does hold the ball up well though.

Hope -6 I thought he had pace, I was wrong. Could and should have scored.

Helan -7 His pace gets us up the field quickly. Some decision making is iffy. Will be unlucky not to replave macguire against city.

Dielna -6 Not really on long enough to influence the game but slotted in no problem.

Overall not our best performance and Reading should have won. The officials were awful. Their penalty was a penalty but we should have had one for handball. Makes up for Bolton.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest tha_knows

Thought Semedo was MOM today, had his best game in a while, absolutely solid, challenged for everything. Westwood, Lees and May the other stand out players aswell. Dunno what's up with Maguire of late, just doesn't seem himself, decision making poor, doesn't seem to make the right runs. Referee, well honestly iv seen some dreadful performances from refs but his has to be one of the worst ever.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest UpTheOwlsss

Westwood 9

Loovens 7

Lees 8

Mattock 7

Palmer 6

Maguire 6

Coke 5/6

Semedo 8

Maghoma 7

May 7.5

Nuihu 7

Coke meh looking forward to seeing hutch or lee back

Palmer wasn't great but defence can't be changed really due to obvious reasons

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Westwood 9

Loovens 7

Lees 8

Mattock 7

Palmer 6

Maguire 6

Coke 5/6

Semedo 8

Maghoma 7

May 7.5

Nuihu 7

Coke meh looking forward to seeing hutch or lee back

Palmer wasn't great but defence can't be changed really due to obvious reasons

Pretty spot on for me. Coke's form seems to have dipped lately, as it often does, and I like Maguire but not much seems to be coming off for him at the moment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No outstanding performers but Westwood is a 10?

I meant as in outfield. No player really wowed anyone today in an attacking sense. Yet I never really felt threatened. Was a gritty 1-0 against a side that will be up there without really playing to our capability. They are the sort of results that separate mid table and play off teams.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...